Sunday, November 27, 2016

Periodic Glaciation and the 100,000 Year Problem


            Only about a million years ago ice ages used to occur more frequently. Periodic glaciation and global cooling occurred every 40,000 years up until a certain point in the earth’s history. We know now that ice ages tend to occur every 100,000 years, and this pattern has been consistent for about a million years. What happened around a million years ago that triggered the transition from 40,000-year ice age periodicity and 100,000-year ice age periodicity is somewhat of an enigma known as “The 100,000 Year Problem”.
            A crucial factor in periodic glaciation is the orbit of earth around the sun. The earth varies in tilt from about 22.5° to 24ยบ approximately every 40,000 years. When the earth is tilted less, less sunlight will contact the poles, allowing ice to build up and melt less. When the earth is tiled more these ice caps receive more sunlight and melt faster. The periods of least tilt correspond to colder temperatures and contribute to the beginnings of ice ages. The periods of most tilt are called “glacial terminations” and mark the mitigation of ice ages. This orbital regularity caused ice ages at a predictable time interval for many millions of years on earth. Something changed around a million years ago that imposed new factors into the periodicity of ice ages.
One of the most important geophysical phenomena occurring on earth is ocean “breathing”. Oceans absorb CO2 naturally and a vast amount is stored deep in the oceans worldwide. Intercontinental ocean currents carry surface water that recently absorbed CO2 down into the depths of the sea as well as bring water that has been at depths for a long time up to the surface where it can release some CO2. In this way the oceans “breathe” as release and intake of CO2 occur simultaneously. Currents tend to be stronger during warm periods on earth and weaker during cold ones, further contributing to the regularity of ice age and between ice age times.

            Fluctuation of CO2 levels due to ocean absorption cause changes in the global temperature. The less CO2 in the atmosphere, the cooler the planet is, and vice versa. Additionally, CO2 levels can fluctuate even more due to ice cap growth. During cooler periods when ice accumulates more, ocean breathing is cut off by glaciers and CO2 trapped inside them. Ice grows, causing lower levels of atmospheric CO2, which leads to cooler temperatures. When ice melts CO2 is released, ocean breathing occurs more readily and temperatures rise. In this way the global temperatures fluctuate and ice ages occur.

            Around 950,000 years ago deep ocean currents weakened significantly and nearly stopped. This caused an upheaval in the pattern of ice age and interglacial (the warm interim between ice ages) periods. When the currents recovered, they then circulated at a different rate, causing a longer time interval between ice ages. Temperatures then rose and fell over a 100,000-year period, and the variance in temperatures became more dramatic. Ice ages were colder and interglacial periods warmer.

Experts from Columbia University and Cardiff University conducted research on this important ocean current shift in order to answer the 100,000 year problem. Deep sea sediments were collected from near South Africa and the ratios of neodymium in the sediments observed. Neodymium is a signature of North Atlantic seawater that flowed down from the northern hemisphere. Higher ratios indicate more flow of seawater from the North Atlantic. The discovered lapse in neodymium isotopes indicates a halt in the flow of the currents around 950,000 years ago. Another piece of evidence was found in small ocean creature’s fossils dating back to that time period. Fossils of plankton and other foraminifera reveal evidence of higher CO2 levels in the ocean’s depths. When the currents subsided, ocean breathing was altered and CO2 was mostly just being absorbed and not released. This caused a large increase in waterborne CO2 that can be seen in the tiny plankton fossils. The temporary cessation of the ocean’s supercurrents caused a large increase in oceanic CO2, a large decrease in atmospheric CO2, and a significant decrease in global temperatures that started a new pattern of ice ages.



Sources
The Earth Institute at Columbia University. (2014, June 26). Ancient ocean currents may have changed pacing and intensity of ice ages. ScienceDaily. Retrieved November 27, 2016 from www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/06/140626141654.htm

             Cardiff University. (2016, October 26). Why does our planet experience an ice age every 100,000 years?. ScienceDaily. Retrieved November 27, 2016 from www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/10/161026081537.htm


 Ocean Carbon Uptake. (n.d.). Retrieved November 28, 2016, from http://www.pmel.noaa.gov/co2/story/Ocean Carbon Uptake 

 Schirber, M. (2005, March 30). Ice Ages Blamed on Tilted Earth. Retrieved November 28, 2016, from http://www.livescience.com/6937-ice-ages-blamed-tilted-earth.html 






Carlin-Type Gold Ore: How Analyzing Fluid Inclusions Helped Determine Its Magmatic-Hydrothermal Orgins

Located in the Northeast corner of Nevada, the Carlin trend is the second largest gold ore deposit on the planet. Carlin-type minerals (gold) are thought to have formed by Hydrothermal replacement (deeply circulating water heated by magma) of organic material in the form of carbonic rock.1 The dissolution of carbonates is followed by the deposition of gold-rich arsenian pyrite (invisible gold). 1 The origin and source of the minerals is hotly debated among geologists. The article, “Trace elements in fluid inclusions of sediment-hosted gold deposits indicate a magmatic-hydrothermal origin of the Carlin ore trend”, argues the unconformity formed by magmatic intrusion in the Mississippian period. The articles also showcases the new methods of confirming highly debated ores by analyzing fluid inclusions. 1 2 The article suggest three possible ways of formation. In the sedimentary model, the formation is a result of heat circulation of meteoric fluid that resulted in the leaching of pre-enriched gold.1 The second model suggests that metamorphic fluids in the lower crust ascended along the bottom of intruding rift faults that displaced gold from “pre-enriched metasediments”.1 2 The third way suggests plutons “exsolved magmatic Gold bearing fluids,” separating into depleted Gold brine and a Gold enriched vapor phase (arsenian pyrite).1 The latter contracting into an aqueous ore fluid during cooling.1

By comparing fluid composition of various intrusions, scientists concluded Carlin ore formed through magmatic intrusions. The ratios of Rb, K, B, As, Sr and Ba with Cu-Au found at Copper Canyon, Nevada cross referenced with Magmatic intrusions in the Alps and China suggests the gold formed from a similar hydrothermal process.1 Proportions of trace elements, show the relatively high levels of B and As but low Rb and K in the fluids.1 These portions resemble magmatic vapor derived fluids derived in Europe that correlate with magmatic vapor-derived fluids found in these particular mines. These results indicate that the origins of the various sources formed from upper crustal magma intrusions that vary in distance from there fluid source.1 2
In the summary of results, the article hints the importance of trace elements ratios in fluid inclusion. By tracking these ratio, we can distinguish the process of fluid to fluid interaction and ultimately determine the source of the inclusion.1 These complex fluid process in highly debated ore systems can now be directly related to “large-scale mass transfer in the crust.”1 By detecting fluid inclusion of trace elements we therefore eliminate the use of ambiguous isotopic dating -- detecting H to O ratios. 1
The Carlin-type deposits contain some of the largest gold deposits in the world but its origins remained a mystery. By analyzing fluid inclusion, scientists were able to confirm that gold deposits had to have originated from a magmatic hydrothermal origin (plutons). This type of analysis can now be used in place of isotopic dating in order to confirm the origins of hotly debated minerals.

Works Cited
1. Large, Simon J.E., Edine Y.N. Bakker, Philipp Weiss, Markus Wรคlle1, and Mike Ressel3And. "Simon J.E. Large." Trace Elements in Fluid Inclusions of Sediment-hosted Gold Deposits Indicate a Magmatic-hydrothermal Origin of the Carlin Ore Trend. N.p., n.d. Web. 27 Nov. 2016.

2. "The Geology of The Carlin Trend | Investing News Network." Investing News Network. N.p., 2015. Web. 27 Nov. 2016.





Glacial sediments provide insight about past and future of Antarctic ice sheet


               The West Antarctic Ice Sheet, which covers the western portion of Antarctica, is rapidly shrinking due to melting ice.  Ice loss has been especially severe in the Amundsen Sea region, where glaciers are losing ice faster than it is being replenished by snowfall.  
Map of the Antarctic ice sheets

               One glacier from this region – Pine Island Glacier – has been the subject of relatively recent interest.  The Pine Island Glacier, which is two kilometers thick and has a surface area rivaling that of Texas, has lost more ice in recent years than any other glacier.  Each year, it thins by more than a meter, as warm seawater eats away at its core.

               Most of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet lies on the sea floor – in other words, it’s “grounded.”  The edges of the ice sheet transition into ice shelves that float on the ocean.  The boundary where the ice sheet loses contact with the underlying bedrock is called the grounding line.  The West Antarctica Ice Sheet is losing more than 150 cubic kilometers of ice each year, and the melting is especially severe at grounding lines.  Researchers who are interested in studying factors that affect the melting rate of glaciers have used the Pine Island Glacier to learn more about grounding line retreat. 

Diagram of grounding line retreat

               It was previously known that the Pine Island Glacier became ungrounded in the 1970s, when it separated from an undersea ridge.  To learn more about how the base of the glacier melted, scientists analyzed sediment core samples from both sides of the ridge.  The sediments were extracted from beneath 450 meters of ice and 500 meters of ocean water.  The analysis revealed that water began to appear on the landward side of the ridge while the ice sheet was still grounded on the ridge’s summit.  This intrusion of ocean water occurred around 1945, following a period of warming in the Pacific Ocean caused by El Niรฑo activity.  The initial cavity in the ice became larger and larger, until the ice shelf completely ungrounded from the ridge. 


               This research is important because glacial melting has a big influence on the global sea level.  The West Antarctic Ice Sheet is “one of the largest potential sources of rising sea levels” (Smith 2016).  The scientists found that even when climatic forces returned to normal and temperatures dropped, the ice sheet continued to retreat.  The water in the hollowed-out cavity never refroze, but continued to eat away at the glacier.  These findings indicate that melting the ice is a difficult process to reverse.  Thus, this issue is important to address now more ever, because even if human-driven warming is curbed, the glacial melting that it has caused could have effects that will become harder to mitigate as time goes on.   
 
SOURCES

Voosen, P. (2016, November 23). In the 1940s, warm ocean waters found Achilles's heel of crucial Antarctic ice sheet. Retrieved November 26, 2016, from http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/11/1940s-warm-ocean-waters-found-achilless-heel-crucial-antarctic-ice-sheet

West Antarctic Ice Sheet. (n.d.). Retrieved November 27, 2016, from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Antarctic_Ice_Sheet