Monday, October 26, 2026

Comparing Mt. St. Helens & Yellowstone: What if the Yellowstone Hotspot Erupted?

A 1-minute search on the internet about the potential caldera-forming eruption of the Yellowstone volcano will result in doom-and-gloom articles, AI-prompted videos of exploding volcanoes, and rumors of humans nearly whipped off the North American continent. In an era where anyone can post whatever they want, it’s unclear what would actually happen if Yellowstone erupted. Would those living in Wyoming and other neighboring states perish? Would the plumes of smoke block out enough of the sun to cool the entire earth’s temperature? Would the agricultural land fail, resulting in famine, death, and a failing economy? These questions are fluttering about the internet, paving the way for dozens of Reddit pages, each full of conspiracy theories and internet trolls. The answer to these questions, however, lies within a comparison between what's going on underground Yellowstone and the history of known explosive volcanic activity such as Mt. St. Helens.

A caldera-forming volcanic eruption requires high concentrations of silica and rhyolitic rock (~75% silica). The more rhyolite there is present, the more silica, and the more explosive the reaction. The explosion at Mt. St. Helens in 1980, for instance, was known for its high percentage of silica. Likewise, Yellowstone is also known for its high silica content. This suggests that if an explosion were to occur, it would be a pyroclastic (highly airborne) reaction, which tends to be far more violent and damaging.

Another important factor for volcanic eruptions lies in the size of the magma chamber. Beneath Mt. St. Helens sit two magma chambers, a small chamber that reaches about 10km deep, and a larger chamber shared with the Indian Heaven Volcanic field, which stretches nearly 40km deep.


This sheer size of this chamber made space for a lot of silica-dense magma, allowing that historic explosion in 1980. Yet the hotspot beneath Yellowstone makes Mt. St. Helens look like a child’s toy. The Yellowstone hotspot is projected to be about 3000km deep, which places it somewhere between the deep mantle and the outer core, and in width, it reaches 350km. That’s about 75 times deeper than Mt. St. Helens. Altogether, this would imply the possibility for a Yellowstone explosion of much greater size than Mt. St. Helens.



This comparison offers the image of a life-altering explosion, complete with magma bombs, huge deposits of new rock, and lots of smoke. Ash from Mt. St. Helens traveled largely to Idaho. From studies of previous Yellowstone reactions that occurred between 2.1 million and 650,000 million years ago, geologists can suspect that another caldera-forming reaction could send particles of ash to western Texas. Using research from other historically-massive volcanic explosions, such as the 1991 eruption of Mt. Pinatubo, geologists can speculate that the ash could have the power to cool the earth for 3-9 years. Rock from the reaction itself could bury all infrastructure within a 60km radius, and devastation from lava and gas could reach across the entire country. The United States would be facing an apocalypse that would affect worldwide trade, communication, and immigration.



As of today, this remains in the hypothetical. Sources suspect that a caldera-forming eruption at Yellowstone would begin with many warning signs, ranging from temperature changes in the magma chamber and astounding earthquakes of high magnitude. Yellowstone has not experienced a giant caldera-forming eruption since approximately 631,000 years ago, and roughly 80 non-explosive eruptions have occurred since then, with the most recent explosion being 70,000 years ago. Some argue that Yellowstone is “overdue” for an eruption, but there is no evidence to suggest that is the case. Even if Yellowstone erupted tomorrow, it might not be a caldera-forming eruption at all, but a calmer flow. Arguably, it would still rival Mt. St. Helens in its place in history, but would not wipe out all of North America. It's worth keeping a close watch on the Yellowstone hotspot, but as of today, the potential for an eruption at Yellowstone remains a "what if."


Sources

“Could a Large Yellowstone Eruption Significantly Change the Climate?” USGS,

        www.usgs.gov/faqs/could-a-large-yellowstone-eruption-significantly-change-climate.

        Accessed 24 Oct. 2026.

Fitzgerald, Erin. “Yellowstone Supervolcano Revealed.” Yellowstone Forever, 13 Apr. 2026, 

        www.yellowstone.org/yellowstone-supervolcano-revealed/.

“Map of the Known Ash-Fall Boundaries for Several U.S. Eruptions.” USGS, Volcano Hazards 

        Program, 2005, www.usgs.gov/media/images/map-known-ash-fall-boundaries-several-us-

        eruptions.

“Mount St. Helens.” USGS, www.usgs.gov/volcanoes/mount-st.-helens. Accessed 24 Oct. 

        2026.

Pomeroy, Ross. What If Yellowstone’s Supervolcano Erupted? | Realclearscience, 10 Oct. 2019, 

        www.realclearscience.com/blog/2019/10/10/what_if_yellowstones_supervolcano_erupted

.html.

“Questions about Yellowstone Volcanic History.” USGS, www.usgs.gov/volcanoes/yellowstone/

        questions-about-yellowstone-volcanic-history. Accessed 24 Oct. 2026.

“The Hot and Cold Journey of Silica Begins in Yellowstone’s Rhyolite and Ends in Geyser 

        Cones, Petrified Trees, and Algae.” USGS, 1 July 2024, www.usgs.gov/observatories/

        yvo/news/hot-and-cold-journey-silica-begins-yellowstones-rhyolite-and-ends-geyser.

“Yellowstone Volcano Observatory.” USGS, www.usgs.gov/yellowstone-volcano-observatory. 

        Accessed 24 Oct. 2026.

2 comments:

  1. This is a really fun read, Rachel. The question of what would happen if Yellowstone erupted is an old one, but you added some really good insights and data. I would be curious to learn more about what the global scale of an eruption would be, how an eruption could affect more than just the area covered by debris etc.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love what-ifs like this; this was a fantastic read. I never would have thought about how only different eruptions from the same hotspot could be felsic or mafic, too! I wonder if a similar thing would happen as in the case of those Miocene Ash Creek fossil beds, where the ash could travel for miles before finally falling and causing some rather major problems for people where it falls. The fact that some of the previous ash beds are way larger than others is also intriguing; what was different about those eruptions? Do we know whether they were felsic or mafic?

    ReplyDelete